AI-generated images raise money for charity. What’s wrong?

kAmuFC?:EFC6 q2?<[ 2 %@C@?E@\32D65 492C:EJ E92E 4@==64ED FD65 9@FD69@=5 :E6>D 7@C A6@A=6 😕 ?665[ DH:E4965 E@ 2CE:7:4:2=\:?E6==:86?46\86?6C2E65 :>286D 😕 :ED a_aa 9@=:52J 42>A2:8?[ C2:D:?8 2 9@DE @7 6E9:42= BF6DE:@?D 2=@?8 H:E9 5@?2E:@?D]k^Am
k5:G 4=2DDlQ25{236=(C2AA6C|2?F2= G:D:3=6\>5 G:D:3=6\=8 :?pCE:4=6{6256C3@2C5 25$:K:?8{6256C3@2C5 DF3D4C:36C\9:56 9:556?\AC:?EQ DEJ=6lQ4=62CiC:89EQm
p#%xr{t r~}%x}&t$ qt{~(
k5:G 4=2DDlQE?E\25D\4@?E2:?6C E6IE\46?E6C Q m
k5:G :5lQ2CE:4=6\:?DE@CJ\=6256C3@2C5\aQ 4=2DDlQE?E\25D 57A\25Q 52E2\=2KJlQECF6Q 52E2\C67C6D9lQECF6Q m
kD4C:AEm
8@@8=6E28]4>5]AFD9W7F?4E:@?WX L
8@@8=6E28]5:DA=2JWV2CE:4=6\:?DE@CJ\=6256C3@2C5\aVXj

NXj
k^D4C:AEm
k^5:Gm
k^5:Gmk^5:Gm
k5:G 4=2DDlQ25{236=(C2AA6C|2?F2= G:D:3=6\D> G:D:3=6\ID 25$:K:?8q:83@I#F?H2J DF3D4C:36C\9:56 9:556?\AC:?EQ DEJ=6lQ4=62CiC:89EQm
p#%xr{t r~}%x}&t$ qt{~(
k5:G 4=2DDlQE?E\25D\4@?E2:?6C E6IE\46?E6C Q m
k5:G :5lQ2CE:4=6\:?DE@CJ\`Q 4=2DDlQE?E\25D 57A\25Q 52E2\=2KJlQECF6Q 52E2\C67C6D9lQECF6Q m
kD4C:AEm
8@@8=6E28]4>5]AFD9W7F?4E:@?WX L
8@@8=6E28]5:DA=2JWV2CE:4=6\:?DE@CJ\`VXj

NXj
k^D4C:AEm
k^5:Gm
k^5:Gmk^5:Gm
k5:G DEJ=6lQ5:DA=2Ji3=@4<Qm
k5:G 52E2\@@GGFF\6>365lQd3b6ehgh\4_54\c5ab\22b3\62“bb6chc64Qm
k2>A\:7C2>6 DC4lQ9EEADi^^A=2J324<]@@GGFF]>65:2^7C2>6^d3b6ehgh\4_54\c5ab\22b3\62“bb6chc64Q H:5E9lQdQ 96:89ElQcQ D2?53@IlQ2==@H\D4C:AED 2==@H\D2>6\@C:8:?Q =2J@FElQC6DA@?D:G6Q 7C2>63@C56ClQ_Q C6D:K23=6 @G6C7=@H A=2469@=56Cmk^2>A\:7C2>6mk^5:Gm
k^5:Gm

kAmtI64FE:G6 5:C64E@C s2? z6CD92H D2:5 E96 =:76=:<6 D46?6D 2C6 >62?E E@ :==FDEC2E6 E96 56D@=2E:@? 2?5 :D@=2E:@? @7 4=:6?ED H:E9@FE @3;64E:7J:?8 @C 569F>2?:K:?8 C62= A6@A=6] tDD6?E:2==J[ E96 492C:EJ 4=2:>D E@ 92G6 7@F?5 2 H2J 2C@F?5 E96 DE:4<J “A@G6CEJ A@C?” DEC2E68J 492C:E:6D 92G6 C6=:65 @? 7@C 564256D]k^Am

kAm“!@G6CEJ A@C? 😀 E96 AC:>2CJ H2J H9:49 @FC D64E@C 92D E@ 5@ E96:C 42>A2:8?D[ 😕 @C56C E@ 86E E96 2EE6?E:@? @7 E96 5@?@CD[” z6CD92H D2:5] “x7 E96J 5:5?’E 5@ :E[ ?@3@5J H@F=5 =@@< 2E E96:C 6>2:=D @C E96:C D@4:2= >65:2 25D @C E96 =:<6[ 2?5 E96J H@F=5?VE C2:D6 7F?5D]”k^Am

kAmw6 D2:5 r2?252’D 492C:E23=6 D64E@C 😀 😕 4C:D:D[ H:E9 >@C6 E92? ge[___ 492C:E:6D 4@>A6E:?8 7@C 7F?5D 2E 2 E:>6 H96? 5@?2E:@?D 2C6 😕 564=:?6 2?5 E96 ?F>36C @7 A6@A=6 H9@ ?665 96=A 😀 C:D:?8]k^Amk5:G :5lV>28?:E6@FEDEC62>V DEJ=6lV=:?6\96:89Ei _AIVmk^5:Gm

kAm$EF5:6D 92G6 D9@H? :>286D 56A:4E:?8 ?682E:G6 6>@E:@?D 86?6C2E6 D:8?:7:42?E=J 3:886C 5@?2E:@?D E92? E9@D6 H:E9 D>:=:?8 7246D] qFE E96C6 92D 366? C646?E AFD9324< 282:?DE D@\42==65 A@G6CEJ A@C?[ H9:49 4C:E:4D 2C8F6 42? A6CA6EF2E6 92C>7F= DE6C6@EJA6D 2?5 C6EC2F>2E:K6 :ED DF3;64ED]k^Amk5:G :5lQE?4>D\C68:@?\2CE:4=60:?DE@CJ0E@AQ 4=2DDlQE?4>D\C68:@? 9:556?\AC:?E EDpCE:4=6#68:@?Qmk5:G :5lQE?4>D\3=@4<\ag_eehaQ 4=2DDlQE?4>D\3=@4< E?E\92D\3=@4<\38QmkD64E:@? :5lQ3=@4<\ag_eehaQ 4=2DDlQ3=@4< 6>A92D:D\9b E?E\?@\>2C8:?\3@EE@>Q mk5:G 4=2DDlQ4=62C7:IQm

k5:G 4=2DDlQ3=@4<\E:E=6 E:E=6\ag_eeha Qm
k5:G 4=2DDlQ3=@4<\E:E=6\:??6CQm
k9bm

*@F >:89E 36 :?E6C6DE65 😕

k^9bm
k^5:Gm
k^5:Gmk^5:Gmk5:G 4=2DDlQ4FDE@>\42C5\=:7E:8?:E6C 42C5\8C:5 Qm
k5:G :5lQ=@25:?8s:G\ag_eehaQ 4=2DDlQ=@25:?8{xQm k: 4=2DDlQ72D E?E\DA:??6C E?E\DA:?Qmk^:m k^5:Gm
k5:G 52E2\7:==65lQ72=D6Q 4=2DDlQDE@CJ!24< A24<ab 42C5\:>8\>5 C68:@?\38Qm
k2CE:4=6 :5lQ42C5\DF>>2CJ\LLFF:5NNQ 4=2DDlQE?E\2DD6E\EJA6\LLEJA6NN A24<$E@CJ` E6>A=2E6 =6EE6C3@I\DEJ=6\H9:E6 E?E\D64E:@?\_Qm
k5:G 4=2DDlQ42C5\4@?E2:?6CQm

k5:G 4=2DDlQ42C5\:>286Qm
k5:G 4=2DDlQ>65:2\AC6G:6H\LLFF:5NN >65:2\AC6G:6H LLEJA6NN\2DD6E Q 52E2\2DA64ElQ`i`Qmk7:8FC6 4=2DDlQA9@E@ =2J@FE\LL@C:6?E2E:@?NN =6EE6C3@I\DEJ=6\H9:E6Qm
k5:G 4=2DDlQ:>286Qm

k2 9C67lQLLFC=NNQ 4=2DDlQE?E\2DD6E\=:?<Q 2C:2\=236=lQLLE:E=6NNQm

k:>8
DC4lQ52E2i:>286^A?8j32D6ec[:’q~#H_zv8@pppp}$&9t&8pppptppppqrp”pppr`wpHrppppr_=t”‘#ca>|g&Hgpp9_q%+F5bqHppppp$&’~#zdr*xxlQ
2=ElQLLE:E=6NNQ
4=2DDlQ:>8\C6DA@?D:G6 =2KJ=@25 7F== H9:E6Q
H:5E9lQQ
96:89ElQQ
52E2\D:K6DlQ2FE@Q
52E2\DC4D6ElQ52E2i:>286^A?8j32D6ec[:’q~#H_zv8@pppp}$&9t&8pppp”ppppsrp”pppp6^(+}pppptt=t”‘#ca>|g&ggpq@H*spqpI”!=EEdKBpppppqy#&dtC<y888llQ ^m
k^2m

k^5:Gm

k^7:8FC6mk^5:Gm
k^5:Gm

k5:G 4=2DDlQ42C5\3@5JQm
k5:G 4=2DDlQ42C5\=236=DQm

k5:G 4=2DDlQ42C5\=236=\7=28DQm
kDA2? 4=2DDlQE?E\7=28 =236= =236=\7=28\LLEJA6NNQmLLEJA6NNk^DA2?m
k^5:Gm

k^5:Gm

k5:G 4=2DDlQ42C5\9625=:?6Qmk9b 4=2DDlQE?E\9625=:?6 Qm

k2 9C67lQLLFC=NNQ 4=2DDlQE?E\2DD6E\=:?<Q 2C:2\=236=lQLLE:E=6NNQm

LLE:E=6NNk^2mk^9bmk^5:Gm
k5:G 4=2DDlQ42C5\>6E2Qm
kF= 4=2DDlQ=:DE\:?=:?6 Qmk=: 4=2DDlQ42C5\52E6Qm
kE:>6 52E6E:>6lQ_Q 4=2DDlQE?E\52E6 2DD6E\52E6 E6IE\>FE65 @=5\2DD6EQm
kDA2? 4=2DDlQ:4@?\H2C?:?8\FA52E65Qmk^DA2?ms64 b`[ `hehk^E:>6mk^=:mk=: 4=2DDlQ42C5\4@>>6?E\4@F?EQmk2 9C67lQLLFC=NNR4@>>6?EDQ 4=2DDlQ4>Qm
k5:G 4=2DDlQG:27@FC2Q DEJ=6lQ5:DA=2Ji:?=:?6Qm

kDA2? 4=2DDlQDC\@?=JQmr@>>6?EDk^DA2?m
k^5:Gm
k^2mk^=:mk^F=m

k^5:Gm

k^5:Gm
k^5:Gm
k^2CE:4=6m
k2CE:4=6 :5lQ42C5\DF>>2CJ\LLFF:5NNQ 4=2DDlQE?E\2DD6E\EJA6\LLEJA6NN A24<$E@CJa E6>A=2E6 =6EE6C3@I\DEJ=6\H9:E6 E?E\D64E:@?\_Qm
k5:G 4=2DDlQ42C5\4@?E2:?6CQm

k5:G 4=2DDlQ42C5\:>286Qm
k5:G 4=2DDlQ>65:2\AC6G:6H\LLFF:5NN >65:2\AC6G:6H LLEJA6NN\2DD6E Q 52E2\2DA64ElQ`i`Qmk7:8FC6 4=2DDlQA9@E@ =2J@FE\LL@C:6?E2E:@?NN =6EE6C3@I\DEJ=6\H9:E6Qm
k5:G 4=2DDlQ:>286Qm

k2 9C67lQLLFC=NNQ 4=2DDlQE?E\2DD6E\=:?<Q 2C:2\=236=lQLLE:E=6NNQm

k:>8
DC4lQ52E2i:>286^A?8j32D6ec[:’q~#H_zv8@pppp}$&9t&8pppptppppqrp”pppr`wpHrppppr_=t”‘#ca>|g&Hgpp9_q%+F5bqHppppp$&’~#zdr*xxlQ
2=ElQLLE:E=6NNQ
4=2DDlQ:>8\C6DA@?D:G6 =2KJ=@25 7F== H9:E6Q
H:5E9lQQ
96:89ElQQ
52E2\D:K6DlQ2FE@Q
52E2\DC4D6ElQ52E2i:>286^A?8j32D6ec[:’q~#H_zv8@pppp}$&9t&8pppp”ppppsrp”pppp6^(+}pppptt=t”‘#ca>|g&ggpq@H*spqpI”!=EEdKBpppppqy#&dtC<y888llQ ^m
k^2m

k^5:Gm

k^7:8FC6mk^5:Gm
k^5:Gm

k5:G 4=2DDlQ42C5\3@5JQm
k5:G 4=2DDlQ42C5\=236=DQm

k5:G 4=2DDlQ42C5\=236=\7=28DQm
kDA2? 4=2DDlQE?E\7=28 =236= =236=\7=28\LLEJA6NNQmLLEJA6NNk^DA2?m
k^5:Gm

k^5:Gm

k5:G 4=2DDlQ42C5\9625=:?6Qmk9b 4=2DDlQE?E\9625=:?6 Qm

k2 9C67lQLLFC=NNQ 4=2DDlQE?E\2DD6E\=:?<Q 2C:2\=236=lQLLE:E=6NNQm

LLE:E=6NNk^2mk^9bmk^5:Gm
k5:G 4=2DDlQ42C5\>6E2Qm
kF= 4=2DDlQ=:DE\:?=:?6 Qmk=: 4=2DDlQ42C5\52E6Qm
kE:>6 52E6E:>6lQ_Q 4=2DDlQE?E\52E6 2DD6E\52E6 E6IE\>FE65 @=5\2DD6EQm
kDA2? 4=2DDlQ:4@?\H2C?:?8\FA52E65Qmk^DA2?ms64 b`[ `hehk^E:>6mk^=:mk=: 4=2DDlQ42C5\4@>>6?E\4@F?EQmk2 9C67lQLLFC=NNR4@>>6?EDQ 4=2DDlQ4>Qm
k5:G 4=2DDlQG:27@FC2Q DEJ=6lQ5:DA=2Ji:?=:?6Qm

kDA2? 4=2DDlQDC\@?=JQmr@>>6?EDk^DA2?m
k^5:Gm
k^2mk^=:mk^F=m

k^5:Gm

k^5:Gm
k^5:Gm
k^2CE:4=6mk^5:Gmk^5:Gmk^D64E:@?mk^5:Gmk^5:Gm

k5:G 4=2DDlQG:27@FC2 G:27@FC2\6?8286>6?E\DE2CE6C DF3D4C:36C\9:56 9:556?\AC:?EQm
kG7\4@?G6CD2E:@?\DE2CE6C
E2C86ElQQ
G7\4@?E2:?6C\:5lQh223fh`2\5geg\cfh7\g7dh\f6dd_b6a“g_Q
E:E=6lQw2G6 J@FC D2J]Q
56D4C:AE:@?lQ{62G6 p r@>>6?E p?5 %6== &D (92E *@F %9:?<]Qm
k^G7\4@?G6CD2E:@?\DE2CE6Cm
k^5:Gm

kDEJ=6m
]G:27@FC2\6?8286>6?E\DE2CE6C L >2C8:?\3@EE@>i `eAIj4=62Ci3@E9 N
]G7\4@?G6CD2E:@?\DE2CE6C0025 L 7=6I\32D:Dib__AIj N
k^DEJ=6m

kAm%96 72>:=:6D uFC?:EFC6 q2?< 96=AD 2C6 @7E6? EC2?D:E:@?:?8 @FE @7 9@>6=6DD?6DD @C 2 A6C:@5 @7 4C:D:D] z6CD92H D2:5 96 4@F=5 ?6G6C 3C:?8 9:>D6=7 E@ 2D< A6@A=6 E@ A@D6 7@C A9@E@D 😕 E92E DE2E6[ D@ :?DE625[ E96 492C:EJ 92D EC25:E:@?2==J 9:C65 A9@E@8C2A96CD E@ D9@@E 92AAJ 4=:6?ED H:E9 E96:C ?6H 7FC?:EFC6 27E6C E96J’G6 366? 96=A65]k^Am

kAm%9:D J62C[ z6CD92H H2D 23=6 E@ E2<6 DE@C:6D HC:EE6? 3J C62= 4=:6?ED[ :?AFE E96> :?E@ px A9@E@ AC@8C2> |:5;@FC?6J[ 2?5 4C62E6 c_ :>286D H:E9 E96 96=A @7 px 2C49:E64E !23=@ !:6EC@A:?E@[ H9@ 25565 A9@E@C62=:DE:4 EH62<D] %9:D 2==@H65 uFC?:EFC6 q2?< E@ 56A:4E D@>6 @7 E96 52C<6DE >@>6?ED 😕 4=:6?ED’ =:G6D H:E9@FE :56?E:7J:?8 E96> 😕 2?J H2J[ 7:?2==J E6==:?8 E96 DE@CJ z6CD92H H2?E65 E96 AF3=:4 E@ 962C]k^Am
k5:G 4=2DDlQ25{236=(C2AA6C|2?F2= G:D:3=6\D> G:D:3=6\ID 25$:K:?8q:886C3@I DF3D4C:36C\9:56 9:556?\AC:?EQ DEJ=6lQ4=62CiC:89EQm
p#%xr{t r~}%x}&t$ qt{~(
k5:G 4=2DDlQE?E\25D\4@?E2:?6C E6IE\46?E6C Q m
k5:G :5lQ2CE:4=6\:?DE@CJ\aQ 4=2DDlQE?E\25D 57A\25Q 52E2\=2KJlQECF6Q 52E2\C67C6D9lQECF6Q m
kD4C:AEm
8@@8=6E28]4>5]AFD9W7F?4E:@?WX L
8@@8=6E28]5:DA=2JWV2CE:4=6\:?DE@CJ\aVXj

NXj
k^D4C:AEm
k^5:Gm
k^5:Gmk^5:Gm

kAm“(6’G6 8@E A6@A=6 D=66A:?8 @? 7=@@CD[ H6’G6 8@E 49:=5C6? 4FC=65 FA 😕 ?6DED @7 4=@E9:?8 2D E96:C 365[” 96 D2:5] “xE’D 2 7@C> @7 9:556? 9@>6=6DD?6DD E92E[ F?=6DD J@F’G6 =:G65 E92E H2J[ :E’D G6CJ 92C5 E@ :>28:?6 =:G:?8 E92E H2J]k^Am

kAm“x’> 2 72E96C] x 4@F=5 ?6G6C 2D< 2 >@E96C[ ‘(@F=5 J@F A=62D6 92G6 J@FC 49:=5 4FC= FA 😕 2 365 @7 4=@E96D D@ E9:D DEC2?86C A9@E@8C2A96C 42? E2<6 A9@E@D D@ E92E H6 42? 8@ 2?5 C2:D6 7F?5D]’ %92E WH@F=5 36X =@8:DE:42==J[ 64@?@>:42==J 2?5 >@C2==J HC@?8]”k^Am

kAmw6 D2:5 E96 px 2AAC@249 =6ED 4=:6?ED A=2J 2? 25G@424J C@=6 H:E9@FE 36:?8 92C>65 3J :>286D @C H@C5D E92E H:== DE:4< H:E9 E96> 7@C6G6C] xE 2=D@ D2G65 9:D 492C:EJ 23@FE Sb_[___]k^Am

kAm%96 C2A:5 DAC625 @7 AC@8C2>D =:<6 |:5;@FC?6J[ sp{{\t 2?5 {6?D2 px 😕 a_aa 92D >256 :E 62DJ 7@C ;FDE 23@FE 2?J@?6 E@ 86?6C2E6 6=23@C2E6 :>286D 😕 D64@?5D] |@C6 E92? `f >:==:@? A6@A=6 92G6 5@H?=@2565 {6?D2 px D:?46 :ED “|28:4 pG2E2CD” 762EFC6 H2D C6=62D65 😕 =2E6 }@G6>36C[ EFC?:?8 A6@A=6’D D>2CEA9@?6 D6=7:6D :?E@ 72?E2DE:42= A@CEC2:ED]k^Am

kAmy@? s62?[ 2 D@4:@=@8J AC@76DD@C H9@ DEF5:6D :>286D @7 9@>6=6DD?6DD[ D2:5 px 😀 2 DE6A 😕 E96 C:89E 5:C64E:@? 😕 E9:D 42D6[ 3FE :E 5@6D?’E ?646DD2C:=J 6=6G2E6 uFC?:EFC6 q2?<’D :>286D @FE @7 E96 “A@G6CEJ A@C?” C62=>]k^Am

kAm“x E9:?< E96J D@=G65 92=7 @7 E96 AC@3=6>[” s62? D2:5] “qJ ?@E :56?E:7J:?8 :?5:G:5F2=D[ E96J’G6 46CE2:?=J D@=G65 2? 6E9:42= 4@?F?5CF>[ H9:49 😀 9@H 5@ J@F D9@H A2:? 2?5 DF776C:?8 @7 9F>2? 36:?8D H:E9@FE 6IA=@:E:?8 DA64:7:4 9F>2? 36:?8D]”k^Am
k5:G 4=2DDlQ25{236=(C2AA6C|2?F2= G:D:3=6\D> G:D:3=6\ID 25$:K:?8q:83@I DF3D4C:36C\9:56 9:556?\AC:?EQ DEJ=6lQ4=62CiC:89EQm
p#%xr{t r~}%x}&t$ qt{~(
k5:G 4=2DDlQE?E\25D\4@?E2:?6C E6IE\46?E6C Q m
k5:G :5lQ2CE:4=6\:?DE@CJ\bQ 4=2DDlQE?E\25D 57A\25Q 52E2\=2KJlQECF6Q 52E2\C67C6D9lQECF6Q m
kD4C:AEm
8@@8=6E28]4>5]AFD9W7F?4E:@?WX L
8@@8=6E28]5:DA=2JWV2CE:4=6\:?DE@CJ\bVXj

NXj
k^D4C:AEm
k^5:Gm
k^5:Gmk^5:Gmk5:G :5lQE?4>D\C68:@?\2CE:4=60:?DE@CJ0>:55=6Q 4=2DDlQE?4>D\C68:@? 9:556?\AC:?E EDpCE:4=6#68:@?Qmk^5:Gm

kAm%96 F?D@=G65 AC@3=6> 😀 E92E 2 42>A2:8? 32D65 2C@F?5 564@?E6IEF2=:K65 :>286D DE:== AFED E96 7@4FD @? :?5:G:5F2= DF776C:?8[ C2E96C E92? E96 C@@E 42FD6D @7 E96 DF776C:?8] #682C5=6DD @7 H96E96C E96 :>286D 2C6 E649?:42==J C62=[ s62? D2:5 E9:D 2AAC@249 A@CEC2JD 2 “56A@=:E:4:K65[ @?6\5:>6?D:@?2= G:6H” @7 A@G6CEJ[ H9:49 😀 2 4@>>@? 4C:E:BF6 =6G6==65 2E E96 492C:E23=6 D64E@C 😕 86?6C2=]k^Am

kAm$@>6 492C:E:6D 6G6? FD6 C62= A9@E@8C2A9D @7 24E@CD 56A:4E:?8 D46?6D @7 A@G6CEJ[ H9:49 H2=<D 2 D:>:=2C =:?6]k^Am

kAm“%96J 92G6 2 E6?56?4J E@ 46?EC6 E96 724E E92E D@>63@5J 😀 DF776C:?8 7C@> 2 =24< @7 D@>6E9:?8 — 😕 E9:D 42D6[ 7FC?:EFC6 — C2E96C E92? 2D<:?8 BF6DE:@?D 23@FE H9J E96J >:89E 36 =24<:?8 E92E 😕 E96 7:CDE A=246[” s62? D2:5]k^Am

kAm$@>6 @7 px’D =@F56DE 4C:E:4D 2C6 A9@E@8C2A96CD[ H9@ 6:E96C D2J E96J 92G6 925 E96:C H@C< DE@=6? 3J :>286 86?6C2E@CD[ @C H@CCJ E92E E96 62D6 @7 4C62E:?8 px :>286D H:== F=E:>2E6=J 56G2=F6 E96:C @H? A9@E@D @C AFE E96> @FE @7 H@C<]k^Am

kAmw6?CJ $49?6==[ AC6D:56?E @7 E96 r2?25:2? pDD@4:2E:@? 7@C !9@E@8C2A9:4 pCE[ D2JD :E’D :>A@CE2?E E@ 2D< H96C6 E96 @C:8:?2= 52E2 42>6 7C@> E@ 7@C> 6249 :>286] x? >@DE 42D6D :E’D :>A@DD:3=6 E@ <?@H[ 3642FD6 E96 AC@8C2>D D4C2A6 >2DD:G6 2C49:G6D @7 :>286D 7C@> 24C@DD E96 :?E6C?6E E@ >2E49 FD6CD’ :?AFE 4F6D] |:5;@FC?6J 7@F?56C s2G:5 w@=K 24<?@H=65865 😕 2 $6AE6>36C :?E6CG:6H H:E9 u@C36D >282K:?6 E92E 9:D 4@>A2?J 5:5 ?@E D66< 4@?D6?E 7C@> =:G:?8 2CE:DED @C 7@C H@C< E92E’D DE:== F?56C 4@AJC:89E]k^Am

kAm$49?6== D2:5 A9@E@8C2A96CD D9@F=5 ?@E DF3;64E C62= 72>:=:6D E@ “A@G6CEJ A@C?” D6EFAD[ 3FE 2C8F65 uFC?:EFC6 q2?<’D 2AAC@249 DH2AD @?6 D6E @7 6E9:4D 7@C 2?@E96C]k^Am

kAm“%96 H:?5@H 2?5 E96 <:5 2?5 E96 365 >FDE 36 4@>:?8 7C@> 2?@E96C :>286 @7 D@>6 D@CE[” 96 D2:5] “xE’D ?@E ;FDE E96 8FJ D:EE:?8 2E E96 4@>AFE6C E92E 92D 5C2H? E92E]k^Am
k5:G 4=2DDlQ25{236=(C2AA6C|2?F2= G:D:3=6\D> G:D:3=6\ID 25$:K:?8q:83@I DF3D4C:36C\9:56 9:556?\AC:?EQ DEJ=6lQ4=62CiC:89EQm
p#%xr{t r~}%x}&t$ qt{~(
k5:G 4=2DDlQE?E\25D\4@?E2:?6C E6IE\46?E6C Q m
k5:G :5lQ2CE:4=6\:?DE@CJ\dQ 4=2DDlQE?E\25D 57A\25Q 52E2\=2KJlQECF6Q 52E2\C67C6D9lQECF6Q m
kD4C:AEm
8@@8=6E28]4>5]AFD9W7F?4E:@?WX L
8@@8=6E28]5:DA=2JWV2CE:4=6\:?DE@CJ\dVXj

NXj
k^D4C:AEm
k^5:Gm
k^5:Gmk^5:Gm

kAm“uC@> 2? 6E9:42= A@:?E @7 G:6H[ J@F’C6 A=28:2C:K:?8] *@F’C6 DE62=:?8] *6D :E D2G6D >@?6J[ 2E H92E 6IA6?D6n”k^Am

kAm%96 492C:EJ’D H63D:E6 24<?@H=6586D px 😀 “DA2H?:?8 7:6C46 5632E6 😕 2CE 4:C4=6D[” 3FE E96 DEC2E68J 92D 82C?6C65 >@DE=J A@D:E:G6 2EE6?E:@?]k^Am

kAmz6CD92H D2:5 E92E H9:=6 5@?2E:@?D 2C6 C@F89=J @? A2C H:E9 =2DE J62C D@ 72C[ uFC?:EFC6 q2?< 92D ?6G6C D66? D@ >F49 6?8286>6?E H:E9 2 9@=:52J 42>A2:8? — 6G6? xztp 92D C624965 @FE 2D<:?8 9@H E@ 96=A] }:?6 @E96C uFC?:EFC6 q2?< =@42E:@?D 92G6 2D<65 7@C A6C>:DD:@? E@ FD6 E96 :>286D[ 2?5 96’D D4965F=:?8 2 H63:?2C E@ E6249 E96> 9@H E@ >2<6 E96:C @H?]k^Am

kAm$E@H6 q@J5[ H9@ C6D62C496D E649?@=@8:42= 6G@=FE:@? 2?5 E96 5:8:E2= 64@?@>J[ D2:5 H6 2C6 364@>:?8 244=:>2E65 E@ 2 H@C=5 😕 H9:49 H6 92G6 E@ BF6DE:@? 6G6CJ :>286 H6 D66 @?=:?6]k^Am

kAm(9:=6 A=28:2C:D> 92D 2=H2JD 6I:DE65 😕 G2C:@FD 7@C>D[ q@J5 D2:5 px AC@G:56D 2?@E96C H2J E@ “568C256 E96 4FCC6?4J @7 2FE96?E:4:EJ” 😕 A9@E@8C2A9J 2?5 HC:E:?8] (96E96C 2FE96?E:4:EJ >2EE6CD 😀 2 >@C6 4@>A=:42E65 BF6DE:@?] x? 9:D G:6H[ 2 ?6HD C6A@CE6C BF@E:?8 2 7:4E:@?2= DEC2H >2? 😕 2? 2CE:4=6[ 7@C 6I2>A=6[ @C 2 492C:EJ AC6E6?5:?8 2? px :>286 H2D C62=[ H@F=5 4C@DD 2? 6E9:42= =:?6]k^Am

kAmq@J5 D2:5 uFC?:EFC6 q2?<’D 42>A2:8? 2AAC@2496D — 3FE DE@AD D9@CE @7 4C@DD:?8 — E92E =:?6]k^Am

kAm“%96J’C6 2EE6>AE:?8 ;FDE E@ AFE 2? :562 😕 J@FC 9625 2?5 E@ AC@G:56 2 G:DF2= 2DA64E @7 H92E :E 😀 E96J’C6 ECJ:?8 E@ 86E 24C@DD 2D 2 >6DD286] |2J36 E92E’D 😕 2 K@?6 @7 2446AE23:=:EJ[ 3642FD6 @7 4@FCD6 H6’5 =:<6 E96 492C:EJ E@ D2G6 >@?6J[ 2?5 E96D6 E@@=D H@C<] p?5 😕 2 D6?D6[ H9@ 42C6D :7 E96C6’D C62==J 2 ‘y2?6 q@H6CD’ @C ?@En” q@J5 D2:5]k^Am
k5:G 4=2DDlQ25{236=(C2AA6C|2?F2= G:D:3=6\D> G:D:3=6\ID 25$:K:?8q:83@I DF3D4C:36C\9:56 9:556?\AC:?EQ DEJ=6lQ4=62CiC:89EQm
p#%xr{t r~}%x}&t$ qt{~(
k5:G 4=2DDlQE?E\25D\4@?E2:?6C E6IE\46?E6C Q m
k5:G :5lQ2CE:4=6\:?DE@CJ\eQ 4=2DDlQE?E\25D 57A\25Q 52E2\=2KJlQECF6Q 52E2\C67C6D9lQECF6Q m
kD4C:AEm
8@@8=6E28]4>5]AFD9W7F?4E:@?WX L
8@@8=6E28]5:DA=2JWV2CE:4=6\:?DE@CJ\eVXj

NXj
k^D4C:AEm
k^5:Gm
k^5:Gmk^5:Gm

kAm“x E9:?< E96J’C6 72==:?8 6E9:42==J 😕 E96 C:89E A=246] qFE x 5@?’E E9:?< E92E >62?D E92E @E96C A6@A=6 H:==]”k^Am

kAmkDA2? 4=2DDlQ6?5?@E604@?EC:3Qmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E96DE2C]4@>^2FE9@CD]>2:>2??0<6G:?]9E>=Qmz6G:? |2:>2??k^2m 😀 2 7C66=2?46 ;@FC?2=:DE 😕 t5>@?E@?]k^DA2?mk^Am